Animation vs Live Action, What Are the Key Differences? How To Choose

Choosing between animation and live-action can feel overwhelming, especially when figuring out how to make an explainer video. For instance, you might lean toward one style over another based on your preferences. But does that choice align with your project goals? This article will compare animation and live-action, exploring how each style can impact your video. Whether you want to create a fun and quirky explainer or something more serious and straightforward, our insights will help you make the right choice for your project. 

Moonb's explainer video production services are a valuable resource for helping you understand your options. Our experienced team can create a captivating animation or live-action video that meets your needs and goals.

What is Animation?

Animation is creating motion and shape change by displaying a series of pictures or frames. These frames consist of:

• Individual drawings
• Paintings
• Illustrations

When played in sequence at a certain speed, animation creates the illusion of movement. It is sometimes called "one of the most versatile visual mediums." Traditionally, animation has been seen as simply a form of entertainment. 

The Evolving World of Animation

In recent years, people of all ages have come to appreciate the versatility and power of animation through its use in movies, education, and more. As the relationship between art and technology continues to evolve, the future holds great potential for animation to expand its reach and influence even further. 

The demand for high-quality animated content is only expected to increase, with animation becoming an increasingly integral part of our daily lives. Animation originated from Latin and derives from the verb Animare, which means “bringing to life” or “breath to life.” 

The Evolution of Animation Techniques

Animation is a technique for manipulating still images into moving images. In traditional animation, transparent celluloid sheets are used to draw or paint images by hand, and the images are photographed and exhibited on film. With time, animation technologies have also evolved, and we have various 2D and 3D animation software (paid and free) and methods to make the animation look more realistic and easy to produce. 

Here are some animation approaches that we use while creating various animated videos: 

• Motion Graphics
• 2D Animation
• 3D Animation
• Whiteboard animation

In short, animation is a video style that has evolved with time and brought new technological inventions.   

The Many Uses of Animation: What Can It Do?  

When we hear animation, the first thought that comes to mind is cartoon movies or series by Disney or Nickelodeon. It is true at some point, but today, animation is used for many different purposes. Animation is used everywhere:

• Feature films
• Short films
• Television series
• Animated GIFs
• Motion graphics
• Video games
• Visual effects 

Here are some prevalent uses of animation: Educational purpose. Marketing purpose. Scientific Visualization purpose. Creative purpose. Game Development purpose. Simulation purpose. And Entertainment purposes.

Related Reading

• What is an Explainer Video
• What is the Purpose of a Storyboard
• Explainer Video Cost
• Explainer Video Script
• How Long Should an Explainer Video Be
• Types of Motion Graphics
• Explainer Video Types

What is Live Action?

Live-action video refers to cinematography or videography that uses real people, places, and things instead of animations or computer-generated effects. It's traditional filmmaking and video production; think of anything from your favorite blockbuster movie to a TV commercial. 

The core characteristic of live-action is its grounding in reality. These videos capture the following:

• Nuances of human expressions
• Natural landscapes
• Physical objects

This offers an immediate sense of authenticity and connection. This realism can evoke more robust emotional responses from the audience, making live-action an effective medium for storytelling and persuasion. 

Types of Live-Action Videos

Live-action videos come in many forms:

• Movies and TV Shows: From Hollywood productions to indie films.
• Commercials: Used in advertising to create relatable and persuasive content.
• Music Videos: Often combining performance with narrative elements.
• Corporate Videos: Including training videos, interviews, and customer testimonials.
• Documentaries: Capturing real-life events or stories. 

The Live Action Video Process 

Here is an overview of the process of creating live-action videos:

You can hire a video production agency to help you with the production process. These agencies are critical if your business is not experienced in holding video shoots. 

There are typically three main stages for producing live-action videos:

• Pre-production
• Production
• Post-production

During pre-production, you typically plan everything you need for the video shoot. This includes choosing:

• A video idea
• Target audience
• Key message

Pre-production also includes scripting and storyboarding to visualize and simulate your video correctly. Once everything is planned, the production stage can occur by filming your corporate video. This is where your video production agency will do excellent work shooting your video. 

You will enter the post-production stage after gathering all the necessary film footage. This includes editing the video with audio, graphics, effects, and adjustments to make it look as you planned. 

Boost Your Content Strategy with Moonb

Moonb is a video marketing agency offering unlimited video editing subscriptions to elevate your content. Key features include:

• Project Management Integration: Seamless collaboration through Trello, Slack, and MS Teams
• Weekly Strategy Calls: Regular check-ins to align with your goals
• Contract-Free, Full-Service Production: A flexible approach without long-term commitments

Why Choose Moonb?

Moonb stands out as a superior alternative to traditional video agencies, freelancers, and in-house production teams, thanks to:

• A flexible, subscription-based model
• Expertise in creating compelling video content

We’re the ideal partner for companies aiming to enhance their marketing and educational efforts through powerful video content.

Start a 3-day free trial with our product demo video service to take your content to the next level.

Animation vs Live Action, What Are the Key Differences?

Animation and live action have strikingly different production processes. Live action involves filming real people, objects, and settings using cameras in real-world locations or studio environments. It requires several stages:

• Pre-production (planning, casting, and location scouting)
• Production (filming scenes with actors and crew)
• Post-production (editing, adding visual effects, and sound mixing)

This process demands extensive coordination of resources and people. In contrast, animation is entirely created from scratch using specialized software or traditional hand-drawn techniques. Artists and animators design characters, settings, and movements, often building entire worlds that are impossible in the real world. The process includes:

• Storyboarding
• Asset creation
• Animation
• Rendering

Unlike live action, animation isn’t constrained by physical laws, allowing limitless creative possibilities.

The Visual Styles and Formats of Animation vs Live Action

Live-action videos present realistic imagery of actual people, events, and environments. This approach is ideal for genres where realism is crucial, such as:

• Dramas
• Documentaries
• Comedies
• Action films

Viewers connect with live action's tangible, familiar aspects, making it relatable and immersive.

On the other hand, animation encompasses a broad spectrum of styles, including:

• Traditional 2D
• Stop-motion
• Modern 3D computer-generated imagery (CGI)

These styles allow for imaginative storytelling, offering artistic freedom to depict fantastical elements, surreal settings, or exaggerated characters. Animated formats range from simple explainer videos to feature-length films with intricate visual details.

The Storytelling and Creative Expression of Animation vs Live Action

Animation provides unmatched creative freedom, enabling storytellers to explore ideas beyond the constraints of the physical world. It allows the creation of:

• Fantastical creatures
• Magical realms
• Abstract visuals

This often uses symbolism and metaphor to convey complex emotions or themes. This flexibility encourages audiences to interpret and engage with the narrative on multiple levels.

Live action brings stories to life with authentic human expressions and interactions. Real actors convey emotions through body language, facial expressions, and dialogue, fostering a sense of relatability and emotional impact. Using actual locations and tangible props further grounds live-action storytelling, making it natural and immersive. 

The Audience Engagement and Demographics of Animation vs Live Action

Traditionally, animation was seen as a medium for children, but this perception has shifted significantly. Today, animated content caters to all age groups, with adult-oriented shows like BoJack Horseman and Rick and Morty gaining popularity. Animation's versatility makes it suitable for both niche audiences and mainstream viewers.

Live action has always engaged a broad demographic due to its relatability and diversity of genres. Its realistic portrayal of human experiences allows it to resonate with audiences across various cultural and age groups. Both mediums can be tailored to specific audiences, but live-action tends to appeal more universally. 

The Cost and Time Investment of Animation vs Live Action

Both animation and live-action can be costly and time-consuming, but their resource requirements differ. Live action involves expenses for:

• Actors
• Crew
• Equipment
• Locations
• Set design
• Time spent on filming and editing

Depending on scale and complexity, costs for live-action projects can range from $17,000 to over $100,000.

Animation requires significant investment in design, animation software, and rendering. While it doesn’t need physical locations or actors, it demands skilled professionals to create and animate each scene. Animated videos typically cost between $15,000 and $35,000 for a 90-second production, but newer subscription-based models for animation services can make them more budget-friendly. 

The Visual Aesthetic of Animation vs Live Action

Live action achieves authenticity by showing real-life people and environments. Its realistic approach makes it emotionally impactful, as audiences can see and relate to human expressions and natural settings. Nevertheless, live action is limited by the physical constraints of the natural world, such as the feasibility of stunts or the availability of locations.

Animation offers complete control over the visual aesthetic, allowing creators to design unique styles and worlds. From vibrant, stylized cartoons to hyper-realistic CGI, animation can adapt its look to suit the story's tone. This medium thrives on its ability to manipulate physics, scale, and other elements to create scenes that live action cannot replicate. 

The Flexibility and Scalability of Animation vs Live Action

Animation is highly flexible and can be repurposed or adapted easily. Since it doesn’t involve physical shoots, changes can be made without requiring reshoots or additional logistical coordination. This makes animation scalable across multiple platforms, from social media snippets to full-length films.

Live action could be more adaptable. Reshoots can be expensive and time-consuming, and changes often require revisiting locations, hiring actors again, or recreating specific setups. While live-action offers realism, it lacks animation's ease of modification. 

The Emotional Connection and Impact of Animation vs Live-Action

Live-action storytelling often excels at forging emotional connections with audiences. Watching real people express emotions, interact, and react to their surroundings creates a relatable and authentic experience. This can be particularly effective for dramas or stories rooted in real-life events.

While less rooted in realism, animation engages viewers through creativity and imagination. Transcending reality can evoke wonder and curiosity, delivering emotionally impactful moments through symbolic visuals and unique artistic techniques.

Related Reading

• B2B Explainer Videos
• Tech Explainer Videos
• Motion Graphics Explainer Videos
• Healthcare Explainer Videos
• Video Production Checklist
• Saas Explainer Videos
• Benefits of Explainer Videos
• Explainer Video Examples
• Explainer Video Characters
• Startup Explainer Video

The Pros and Cons of Using Animated vs Live Action Videos

Pros of Animation Videos

Unlimited Creative Freedom

One of the biggest advantages of animation is the freedom it provides to the creators. With animation, there are no limits to the imagination. Animators can create characters, environments, and scenarios that would be impossible to recreate in live-action. This freedom allows for limitless creativity and a wide range of possibilities, making video animation for businesses a popular choice for many projects.

Cost Effective

Animation is often more cost-effective. Unlike videos, which require travel and search for shoot locations, animation requires talented animators and the right software. This makes it a more affordable option for many businesses and organizations looking to create engaging video content. Animation explainer videos are a great way to showcase the product/service without being monotonous.

Ability to Create Unrealistic Scenarios

The creative potential of animation is vast, enabling the creation of scenarios beyond what is possible in reality. Animation enables artists to bring their visions to life, from imagined realms to futuristic societies. Thus, it is a favored medium for science fiction, fantasy, and other genres that require an imaginative backdrop. 

Cons of Animation Videos

Time-Consuming

Creating an animated video can be a time-consuming process. From designing characters and environments to animating movement and adding special effects, the process can take weeks or even months to complete, depending on the project's complexity. This can be a drawback for businesses and organizations that need to produce videos quickly.

Limited to Animator's Skills

The quality of an animated video heavily depends on the animators' skills. If the animators are experienced and talented, the final product can stay relevant to the intended message. On the other hand, live-action videos can often be improved through editing, whereas animation is much more complex to edit once created.

Lack of Realism

While animation provides the freedom to create unrealistic scenarios, it can also be a disadvantage in certain situations. When attempting to convey real-life situations, video animation for businesses can struggle to develop a sense of realism, making it less effective in communicating specific messages or emotions.

For example, The true essence of a testimonial video can only be achieved through live videos.

Pros of Live-Action Videos

Realism

One of the biggest advantages of live-action videos is their closeness to reality. Live-action videos are shot with real actors in real-world locations, which provides a level of realness that is difficult to achieve with animation. This can be especially important for businesses and organizations wanting to convey authenticity and connection with their audience.

Live event video services companies provide are a great way to showcase the real side of your brand.

Emotional Impact

Another advantage of live-action videos is the emotional impact they can have on the audience. With live-action, viewers can personally connect with the characters and events, increasing engagement and building emotional resonance. 

This can be especially important for advertisements, testimonial videos, public service announcements, and other videos that evoke a specific emotion or response.

Flexibility

Live-action videos are also more flexible than animation. If changes need to be made during the production process, it is often easier to make adjustments in live action than in animation. For example, a scene can be re-shot, or an actor can be replaced without extensive redrawing or re-animation. 

This flexibility can make the production process more efficient and help ensure that the final product meets the client's needs. Live-action videos offer the benefits of realism, emotional impact, and flexibility.

Cons of Live-Action Videos

Cost  

One of the biggest disadvantages of live-action videos is cost. Live-action productions often require a larger budget than animated videos, as they require:

• Actors
• Sets
• Costumes
• Special effects
• Other resources

This can make live-action less accessible for businesses and organizations with limited budgets.

Constraints of Reality

Another disadvantage of live action is the constraints of reality. In live action, the events and the settings in which they occur are limited by the physical laws of the real world. This can make it difficult to create certain scenarios, such as fantastical creatures and magical worlds, which are easily achieved in animation. 

Logistics

Another challenge in live-action videos is logistics. Shooting on location, managing actors, and coordinating the many elements involved in a live-action production can be complex and time-consuming. This can make live-action less efficient than animation, especially for projects with tight deadlines.

Factors Influencing the Choice of Animation vs Live Action

When choosing between animation and live-action video, the first thing to consider is what you promote and the industry it pertains to. For example, live-action explainer videos may be more appropriate for industries that rely on real-life interactions, like hospitality or retail. 

On the other hand, animation can be more effective for other industries, such as technology or any sector that wants to simplify its complex products or services. This is because animated videos can take abstract ideas and turn them into digestible visual representations. 

What Is Your Budget for the Video? 

Next, think about your budget for creating the video. Live-action videos can incur costs for hiring 

actors, renting equipment, and securing locations. On the other hand, animated videos require payment for animation services, which can also amount to a considerable sum. 

Live-action videos would be significantly less expensive than animated explainer videos. Still, high-quality animated videos can also be costly, so figuring out what works for your budget is crucial. 

What is Your Timeline for Completion? 

Consider your timeline for video completion. Creating animated videos can take some time, as animators must first create all the elements in graphic design and then animate all the frames together. 

Live-action videos can also be time-consuming, considering they require sorting everything from the location to the crew to the cast. Also, shooting the video can be unpredictable and may take longer than expected, especially if things are not planned out thoroughly.

Related Reading

• Motion Graphics Companies
• Promotional Video Production Companies
• 30 Second Explainer Videos
• Top Explainer Video Companies
• Product Video Companies
• Stop Motion Animation Examples
• App Explainer Video
• 3d Video Production Companies
• Best Explainer Video Software
• 2d Explainer Video
• 3d Explainer Videos

Start a 3-day Free Trial to Take Your Content to the Next Level with Our Product Demo Video Service

Animation and live-action are two distinct styles of video production. In live-action videos, real people and locations bring your story to life. Animation, on the other hand, creates your video through illustration or graphics. With animation, you can tell your story using custom-made characters and unique settings that don’t even have to exist in the real world. 

For this reason, animation offers much more creative freedom than live action. And while both styles can help you achieve your goals, they each have pros and cons. 

‍

‍